BGCT wants to ‘review and consider changes’ in its relationship to Baylor (2022)

Thirty-two years after the Baptist General Convention of Texas fought to retain a say in the governance of Baylor University, Texas Baptists may willingly change that agreement.

The BGCT now hopes to “review and consider changes” to its 1990 agreement with Baylor University, according to Executive Director David Hardage, speaking to the Baptist Standard.

Hardage responded to a direct question from the Standard about the future relationship of the state convention and the university.

Like the Standard, Baptist News Global had received a news tip in late July that the special relationship between the BGCT and Baylor might be changing. Contacted by BNG at the time, an official spokesperson for Baylor deflected the question.

BGCT wants to ‘review and consider changes’ in its relationship to Baylor (1)

David Hardage

Then on Aug. 16, Hardage responded to a request for comment from the Standard by saying: “The BGCT has entered into initial conversations with Baylor University to review and consider changes to the special agreement between our two institutions. Conversations are kind, gracious and cooperative, but will take some time to complete. We will share additional information as it comes available.”

Baylor then released a response: “For more than 175 years, Baylor University and Texas Baptists have served side by side to extend the kingdom of God in Texas and beyond. We remain firmly rooted in our shared history, andthe university is committed to continuing to maintain its historic relationship with the BGCT and with Texas Baptists.Such a commitment is at the heart of Baylor’s motto —Pro Ecclesia, Pro Texana, or ‘for the church’ and ‘for Texas.’”

It now appears that the request for reconsideration originated with the BGCT, not with Baylor. And there is informed speculation that this is a precursor to a push to require all entities that partner with the BGCT to adhere to its anti-LGBTQ stance — which Baylor appears unlikely to do.

History of the two groups

Baylor University dates to 1845, when the school received a charter from the Republic of Texas at the request of the Texas Baptist Education Society, a predecessor organization to the state convention. One of the leaders of that early effort was R.E.B. Baylor, who would become the namesake of the Baptist college.

From 1886 until 1990, the convention elected all of Baylor’s governing board.

The state convention was organized in 1848, and from 1886 until 1990, the convention elected all of Baylor’s governing board. That suddenly changed on Sept. 21, 1990, when Baylor trustees unilaterally amended the school’s charter to create a self-perpetuating board. This was done to prevent a “fundamentalist takeover” of the university as a “conservative resurgence” swept across the Southern Baptist Convention and threatened to spill over into state conventions.

(Video) 2022 BGCT Champion of Club Champions - PAIRS SEMI FINAL

That threat eventually was realized, as most all state Baptist conventions fell in line with the new conservative direction of the SBC. The two most notable holdouts at the time were the BGCT and the Baptist General Association of Virginia.

This was the context in which Baylor trustees — all appointed by the BGCT — became Baylor regents appointed by themselves. And it was the context in which Baylor regents eventually agreed to a second charter amendment that allowed the BGCT to elect 25% of the board of regents, with an important escape clause.

The university’s bylaws as dated May 14, 2021, state: “In the election of the Regents elected by the Board of Regents, the University will be receptive to suggestions from Texas Baptists and will give due and careful consideration to the suggestions of The Baptist General Convention of Texas (the “Convention”) of persons to be nominated for election to the Board of Regents.”

“The University will be receptive to suggestions from Texas Baptists and will give due and careful consideration to the suggestions.”

The bylaws then add: “The Convention may elect up to 25% of the BGCT Regents in office, the specific number of which shall be determined and allocated by the Baylor Board of Regents. The authorization to elect is a delegation of authority from the Baylor University Board of Regents and can be changed unilaterally by the University as it has full legal right, power and authority to amend or rescind its certificate of formation, bylaws and other governing documents without approval or consent of the Convention or any other party notwithstanding the terms and conditions of any relationship agreement.”

Why a change might be coming

As the nation’s largest university still loosely affiliated with a state Baptist convention, Baylor is not dependent upon the BGCT for its success or survival. The state convention provides only a fraction of the university’s annual income, and most of that is designated for scholarships and campus ministries. Nor is Baylor dependent on the state convention for student recruitment, as being part of Baylor’s religiously diverse student body is a top draw for high-performing students across the nation.

BGCT wants to ‘review and consider changes’ in its relationship to Baylor (2)

Baylor President Linda Livingstone announces in 2021 that the university had surpassed $1 billion in giving to its current fundraising campaign.

If anyone should want to change the current pattern of seating members of the board of regents, it would most naturally be Baylor, which has ceded minority control on its board to a state convention that has increasingly shifted to the right politically and theologically and has little financial skin in the game.

But that does not appear to be the present impetus for change. Instead, the BGCT appears to have instigated the conversation.

Why, though?

Although leaders of neither body have explained what’s happening, the Baptist Standard article points to Texas Baptists’ concerns about LGBTQ issues as a possible cause.

(Video) 2022 BGCT Champion of Club Champions - PAIRS FINAL

“Some Texas Baptists have made known their opposition to Baylor’s decision to grant a charter toPrism, an LGBTQ student organization, on April 19,” the Standard said. “On May 3, the BGCT posted astatementon its website from Hardage: ‘We are aware of the recent chartering of the Prism at Baylor student organization by Baylor University. We have heard concern expressed by many in the Texas Baptists family and are in the process of communicating those concerns to university leadership. There has been some confusion regarding the group’s chartering, and we are seeking clarification to determine the best course of action moving forward. TheBGCT’s positionon Human Sexuality and Biblical Marriage has not and will not change.’”

In short, that position is that Texas Baptists oppose any tolerance of same-sex relations, same-sex marriage and transgender identity.

Texas Baptists oppose any tolerance of same-sex relations, same-sex marriage and transgender identity.

Baylor, meanwhile, has walked a public tightrope on LGBTQ issues, with its board of regents reportedly divided on the issue. Yet seeking and maintaining its status as a top-tier research university with a diverse faculty and student body requires more demonstrations of inclusion than Baylor previously has given.

At the same time, Baylor is cited in a federal lawsuit brought against the U.S Department of Education by a coalition of LGBTQ students and alumni of two dozen faith-based schools. The students and alumni claim these faith-based schools should not be able to receive millions of dollars in federal grants and scholarships while violating federal mandates against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender.

After years denying a charter for an on-campus student group for LGBTQ persons, the university last year relented and offered a small concession that would allow a limited expression of such a group to exist.

A university news release said of the May 2021 action: “The board charged the president and university administration to determine the appropriate pathways to provide additional care, connections and community for Baylor’s LGBTQ students, including the possibility of establishing a new, chartered student group that is consistent with Baylor’s core commitments and the university’s policies and statements.”

That mere “possibility” set off a firestorm of protest from the right, including from BGCT leaders.

Then on April 22 this year, the Baylor Lariat, the student newspaper, reported a charter had been granted to a new student group called Prism. The group describes its purpose thus: “The mission of Prism serves Baylor University and its students through creating a respectful space that embraces diverse sexual identities (community) focused on continuous learning for the Baylor community, giving voice for LGBTQ+ students to the administration (care), and creating opportunities for all students to access resources through connection, belonging, and education.”

To LGBTQ advocates and allies, this single action is too little and too late. But to conservative pastors who control the leadership of the BGCT, it is a step too far.

(Video) 2022 BGCT District State Mixed Pairs Finals Day 03.04.22

To LGBTQ advocates and allies, this single action is too little and too late. But to conservative pastors who control the leadership of the BGCT, it is a step too far.

BGCT’s rightward shift

If the BGCT amends its relationship with Baylor University, it will happen as one further mark of the once-moderate convention’s rightward shift over the past decade.

In 1998, the BGCT was so resistant to fall in line with the new direction of the SBC that hundreds of conservative churches left the BGCT and formed their own state convention, called the Southern Baptists of Texas Convention. In more recent years, BGCT leaders have drawn closer to the SBC and have distanced themselves from the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, one of the breakaway groups born of the SBC schism.

For several years, the BGCT allowed churches to send contributions to CBF through the state convention, but that no longer is allowed. Texas churches may send contributions through the BGCT to the SBC, but not to CBF.

The historic relationship between the BGCT and Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty also has been strained in recent years, with BGCT less involved and less visible. Likewise, the BGCT’s own Christian Life Commission — once a public advocate for traditional views on church-state separation — has been hidden away in a Center for Cultural Engagement with four other unrelated ministries.

The most visible shift occurred in 2016 when the BGCT declared churches that welcome and affirm LGBTQ Christians “out of harmonious cooperation.”

The most visible shift occurred in 2016 when the BGCT declared churches that welcome and affirm LGBTQ Christians “out of harmonious cooperation,” effectively expelling two high-profile congregations. That created national headlines. Three years later, the Dallas pastor who made the motion to expel the churches was hired as associate executive director of the convention.

Last year, the BGCT adopted a resolution that “affirmed” women as leaders in the church, although the convention does not publicly support women in ministry as it once did. And BGCT leadership rolled out a new faith statement that draws a line in the sand against transgender persons, stating: “Gender is a gift from God who creates humankind male and female in the divine image and likeness.”

One of the most complicated relations the BGCT has is to Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, an SBC school in Fort Worth, Texas. From the early 20th century until 1994, the BGCT and Southwestern Seminary enjoyed a close relationship, even though the seminary was managed by the SBC, not the BGCT. The vast majority of Texas Baptist pastors were educated at Southwestern.

But when the newly empowered conservative majority on Southwestern’s trustee board fired popular president Russell Dilday in March 1994, BGCT leaders were offended and distressed.

Just one year earlier, Baylor regents had approved creation of a new Texas seminary at Baylor to be named for legendary Dallas pastor George W. Truett. The new seminary, based in Waco, opened its doors in the fall of 1994, six months after Dilday was fired at Southwestern.

The hope of many in BGCT leadership at the time was that Truett Seminary would become the primary training ground for Texas Baptist pastors.

(Video) The destructive power of toxic masculinity hiding behind the concept of “Biblical Womanhood”

The hope of many in BGCT leadership at the time was that Truett Seminary would become the primary training ground for Texas Baptist pastors, replacing Southwestern, which had taken a sharp turn to the right theologically. While Truett has graduated more than 1,000 students in 28 years, it has not supplanted Southwestern’s influence in the state.

David Hardage, who was elected BGCT executive director 10 years ago, came to the role from the staff of Truett Seminary. However, in recent years he has developed a closer relationship with Southwestern than at any time in 30 years. And now Hardage is retiring, and a search committee is seeking his successor.

For now, there are more questions than answers about what’s happening between the BGCT and Baylor, and both groups are being circumspect in their comments. But if the BGCT amends its governance relationship with Baylor, the biggest question may be what happens to its relationship with Truett Seminary.

A small group of conservative Texas pastors already forced the closure of Logsdon Seminary at Hardin-Simmons University, another school affiliated with the BGCT. While administrators and trustees said the seminary was closed for financial reasons, faculty, students and alumni have not bought that answer. In their view, the West Texas seminary was closed because it was perceived as too liberal on the inclusion of women and LGBTQ Christians.

Making similar charges stick against Truett Seminary would be more difficult, because the Baylor-affiliated seminary has attempted to ride the fence in the same way the university has. What could be happening right now is that the BGCT is calling their hand.

Related articles:

What should it cost a denomination to control governance of a university?

Class action lawsuit on LGBTQ discrimination at faith-based schools continues to gain momentum

Baylor walks the line on LGBTQ student group as critics pounce from the right| Analysis by Mark Wingfield

A new scholarship for students who advocate care and justice for LGBTQ persons garnered the most support on Baylor Giving Day

At Baylor University, the debate about LGBTQ students also is shaped by a network of churches embracing conversion therapy

What happened to Texas Baptists? Moderate churches shaken by perceived shift to the right


Is Baylor associated with the Southern Baptist Convention? ›

Though Baylor is a Baptist university, it is affiliated with the Baptist General Convention of Texas (the BGCT plays a role in electing 25% of the Board of Regents), not the SBC. However, many churches throughout Texas and the rest of the country are members of or are affiliated with the SBC.

When was Baylor founded? ›

Where did Baylor University start? ›

In 1841, delegates to the Union Baptist Association meeting accepted the suggestion of Reverend William Milton Tryon and District Judge R.E.B. Baylor to establish a Baptist university in Texas.

What religious affiliation is Baylor? ›

“Baylor's a religious school. It's affiliated with the Baptist General Convention of Texas.

Is Baylor University still a Baptist school? ›

Chartered in 1845 by the Republic of Texas and affiliated with the Baptist General Convention of Texas, Baylor is both the state's oldest institution of higher learning and the world's largest Baptist university.

Is Baylor a prestigious school? ›

The Carnegie Classification of Institutions of Higher Education recognizes Baylor University as a "Doctoral University: Very High Research Activity" or "Research 1" institution, joining the nation's top-tier research institutions as a doctoral university with very high research activity and elevating Baylor as a ...

What major is Baylor known for? ›

The most popular majors at Baylor University include: Registered Nursing/Registered Nurse; Biology/Biological Sciences, General; Communication, General; Health/Medical Preparatory Programs, Other; Accounting; Finance, General; Psychology, General; Marketing/Marketing Management, General; Political Science and ...

What is Baylor University acceptance rate? ›

What does Baylor look for in a students? ›

Baylor University is selective with an acceptance rate of 45%. Students that get into Baylor University have an SAT score between 1200–1380 or an ACT score of 25–32. Regular applications are due February 1.

Does Baylor have a nice campus? ›

The Baylor campus is considered one of the most beautiful in the country. Alexander Hall was opened on September 13, 1940, and currently provides housing for the Honors Residential College.

What makes Baylor University special? ›

Baylor is special because bonds of friendship grow strong and sturdy here. Baylor is also special because of the number and quality of programs available for faculty, staff, and student participation.

What is the GPA requirement for Baylor University? ›

With a GPA of 3.72, Baylor requires you to be above average in your high school class. You'll need at least a mix of A's and B's, with more A's than B's.

Is alcohol allowed at Baylor? ›

Law and Baylor policy prohibit the unlawful manufacture, possession, use, sale, transfer, or purchase of alcohol on or off Baylor property or as part of any of Baylor's activities, or attempt to engage in any such prohibited behavior.

Is Baylor a dry campus? ›

Baylor prohibits alcohol on campus, including in student residences. Students cannot consume alcohol at any official Baylor off-campus event or property. This policy applies to all students regardless of their age.

Is Baylor Ivy League? ›

No, Baylor University is not an Ivy League school, but it has been educating students for more than 175 years. All Ivy League schools are located in the Northeast, with many dating to colonial times.

Is Baylor University a Mormon school? ›

Baylor University was chartered in 1845 by the republic of Texas and is Texas' oldest institution of higher education. It is governed by a predominantly Baptist Board of Regents and is operated within the Christian-oriented aims and ideals of Baptists.

What do Baylor Bears say? ›

BAYLOR! BEARS! FIGHT! And win all our victories for the Green and Gold!

Is Baylor or A&M a better school? ›

College and universities are evaluated based on academic quality, net cost of attendance, and financial aid numbers; all told, Baylor comes in at No. 82 nationally. (A few others schools' “Best Value” rankings for comparison: Texas A&M ranks 89th, TCU 96th, SMU 158th, and UT 186th.)

Is Baylor a Tier 1 school? ›

“Through top-tier research, scholarship and external funding support, R1 universities — that now include Baylor University — bring their voice to bear in addressing our world's most significant challenges,” says President Linda Livingstone.

Is Baylor worth the money? ›

Based primarily on its reputation, Baylor University is a high value school, placing it in the top 20% of schools in terms of value. Baylor gets this verdict primarily on the school's reputation. On college ranking lists, it often ranks between #50 and 100, putting it roughly in the top 10% of schools.

What is the best program at Baylor? ›

BEST is a yearlong academic leadership cohort comprised of the "leaders of leaders" within the Hankamer School of Business. The purpose of the program is to identify, select, and recruit -- and then educate, develop, and launch -- the world's future global Christian business leaders from Baylor University.

Are Baylor classes hard? ›

Classes are generally difficult. It's an academically rigorous school, and if you graduate, you've definitely earned it. Students spend a lot of time studying, for the most part, but there's also a lot of free time.

Can I get into Baylor with a 3.4 GPA? ›

Is your high school GPA good enough for Baylor University? The average high school GPA for admitted students at Baylor University is 2.0 on a 4.0 scale. (You can calculate your high school a GPA here.)

What college has the lowest acceptance rate? ›

Top 100 - Lowest Acceptance Rates
SchoolLocationFall 2021 Acceptance Rate
Princeton UniversityPrinceton, NJ4%
Stanford UniversityStanford, CA4%
Yale UniversityNew Haven, CT5%
Brown UniversityProvidence, RI6%
17 more rows

Is Baylor Medical School hard to get into? ›

Most years, Baylor Med accepts approximately 5.3% of its applicants. But in 2021, only 84 of the 402 people who applied to the school received interviews with college staff, and only 12 received offers of admission. That's an acceptance rate of a mere 3.5%!

What GPA is required for Baylor College of Medicine? ›

Applicants should have an average GPA of 3.8/4 (90%) or higher. All candidates must take the Medical College Admission Test sponsored by the Association of American Medical Colleges. MCAT scores that are three years old or less are accepted by Baylor College of Medicine.

Can you get into college with a 2.1 GPA? ›

A 2.1 GPA indicates that you have around a C average across all of your classes. This is a low GPA, so you may end up experiencing some difficulties in the college admissions process. 0.45% of schools have an average GPA below a 2.1. You can apply to colleges and have a good shot at getting admitted.

What GPA is required for Harvard? ›

You should also have a 4.18 GPA or higher. If your GPA is lower than this, you need to compensate with a higher SAT/ACT score. For a school as selective as Harvard, you'll also need to impress them with the rest of your application.

Why is Baylor popular? ›

Baylor consistently ranks in the top 100 national doctoral-granting universities in "America's Best Colleges" by U.S. News & World Report. Graduate programs in law, business, health disciplines, nursing, the sciences and education are nationally ranked in the 2020 "America's Best Graduate Schools" by U.S. News.

What is the average class size at Baylor University? ›

The student to faculty ratio is 16 to 1. The average undergraduate class size is 28. More than 100,000 Baylor alumni reside in Texas.

Why is Baylor good? ›

Baylor has been aiming to become one of the most elite schools in the South. The best thing about Baylor is it's integration of excellent academics, exciting sports teams, Greek life, and Christianity.

Why do students choose Baylor? ›

Baylor University is a well-known school for higher education for many obvious, good reasons, such as it being a Nationally-Ranked Research University, and its athletics being in the competitive Big 12 Conference.

Is Baylor University a good school for pre med? ›

Founded in 1845, Baylor has a great track for medical school admission, helping over 250 plus students matriculate each year. It comes in at #76 in the National University Rank, according to U.S. News. Here's more information on their Baylor's pre-med and Prehealth support services…

Is it hard to get into Baylor nursing program? ›

Admission to the School of Nursing is competitive, and priority is given to applicants that have taken at least 32 credits of their 66 credits of general education classes at Baylor in Waco. To be eligible to apply, students must have a 3.0 GPA, with all grades being at least a C.

Is the Baptist church declining? ›

Membership in Southern Baptist congregations continued its long-term decline with a 3% drop from 14,089,947 in 2020 to 13,680,493 in 2021.

Do Southern Baptist believe in speaking in tongues? ›

Southern Baptists have long viewed speaking in tongues with ambivalence, not exactly condemning a practice that's mentioned in the Bible, but not allowing it from its pastors and churches.

Why did the Southern Baptist Convention split? ›

This difference came to a head in 1845 when representatives of the northern states refused to appoint missionaries whose families owned slaves. To continue in the work of missions, the southern Baptists separated and created the Southern Baptist Convention.

What do Southern Baptist believe about cremation? ›

Is Burial The Preferred Choice In The Baptist Church? When it comes to burial or cremation, Southern Baptists (and anybody within the Baptist faith) have the right to choose. There is no ban on cremation, and it is unlikely that a church leader would refuse a person's right to choose this over a burial.

Which denomination is losing the most members? ›

The Presbyterian Church has had the sharpest decline in church membership: between 2000 and 2015 they lost over 40% of their congregation and 15.4% of their churches. Infant baptism has also decreased; nationwide, Catholic baptisms are down by nearly 34%, and ELCA baptisms by over 40%.

Are Baptist and Southern Baptist the same? ›

Southern Baptists are the largest evangelical Protestant group in the United States. Descended from Baptists who settled in the American colonies in the 17th century, Southern Baptists formed their own denomination in 1845, following a rift with their northern counterparts over slavery.

Do Southern Baptists have female pastors? ›

Nonetheless, by 1987, Southern Baptist churches had ordained nearly 500 women, 18 of whom served as pastors. Women in Ministry, SBC changed its name to Southern Baptist Women in Ministry to highlight the organization's independence from the Southern Baptist Convention.

Why do Baptists not believe in tongues? ›

First, Southern Baptists cannot permit its missionaries to pray in tongues because what the latter claim is the biblical gift is not. The biblical gift of tongues was always “a legitimate language of some people group,” so the policy declares.

What churches speak tongues? ›

All denominations that embrace Pentecostal theology speak in tongues, including the Assemblies of God, the Church of God, Foursquare churches, Apostolic churches, and Vineyard churches. Individuals who speak in tongues can be found in many other denominations like Baptist, Methodist, and Nazarene.

What does the Bible say about speaking in tongues? ›

For anyone who speaks in a tongue does not speak to men but to God. Indeed, no one understands him; he utters mysteries with his spirit. But everyone who prophesies speaks to men for their strengthening, encouragement and comfort. He who speaks in a tongue edifies himself, but he who prophesies edifies the church.

Is Southern Baptist Calvinist? ›

While the Southern Baptist Convention remains split on Calvinism, there are a number of explicitly Reformed Baptist groups in the United States, including the Association of Reformed Baptist Churches of America, the Continental Baptist Churches, the Sovereign Grace Baptist Association of Churches, and other Sovereign ...

What Bible do Southern Baptists read? ›

In response to this perceived menace, the SBC commissioned its own Bible translation, the Holman Christian Standard Bible, which was finalized in 2003.

What religion does Baptist fall under? ›

Baptist, member of a group of Protestant Christians who share the basic beliefs of most Protestants but who insist that only believers should be baptized and that it should be done by immersion rather than by the sprinkling or pouring of water.

When a body is cremated what happens to the coffin? ›

What Happens to the Coffin During Cremation? Yes, the coffin is cremated along with the body and everything inside. The container the deceased is laid in before it's placed into the chamber is cremated along with the body. Once the coffin enters the crematorium, it is legally not allowed to be opened.

Can you ascend to heaven if you are cremated? ›

No matter what a person's preference is, from the Christian perspective, cremation does not prevent one from going to Heaven. So there's no need to worry, if God can create life from dust, surely he can restore life from ashes.

Is the Bible against cremation? ›

Since the Bible does not ban nor promote cremation, most Christian denominations do not consider cremation to be sinful. The Catholic church, however, held an opposing view for many years.


1. How Toxic Masculinity is rooted in the theory of "Biblical Womanhood."
(Vote Common Good)
2. Southern Baptist Convention launches reforms to combat sexual abuse
(CBS Mornings)
3. Pastoral Letter - A Response to the SBC 3rd Party Report
(Woodland Baptist Church)
4. 04/25/2021 Evening Service
(First Baptist Brownfield)
5. 2022 BGCT Champion of Club Champions - FOURS FINAL
(Bowls Gold Coast-Tweed)
6. Networking Conversation: Decision Fatigue
(Texas Baptists)

Top Articles

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Arielle Torp

Last Updated: 12/19/2022

Views: 5976

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arielle Torp

Birthday: 1997-09-20

Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

Phone: +97216742823598

Job: Central Technology Officer

Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.